Translate

Monday, May 27, 2019

Resurrection Resurrected



T
oday is in Christian tradition the Sixth Sunday of Easter. I can't get enough of Easter because it's about the resurrection of the body. Years ago I read Norman O. Brown's Life Against Death, in which his last chapter is entitled "The Resurrection of the Body."[1] Brown, a rather orthodox Freudian, opened my eyes to see that the thrust of resurrection is the affirmation of the mortal body. He argued that the real dynamic going on in humanity's struggle to become conscious (and free of neurosis) was that between life and death. He further asserted that the only way humanity would ever get out of the trap of its own neuroses was to stop sublimating sexual drive and negating, limiting, and repressing pleasure. And that he said was the treasure that lay buried in Christianity in the form of the resurrection of the body.

I have literally been unpacking that for almost 50 years. Today was one of many occasions when I have preached on the theme of resurrection, hoping to edge people out of the notion that it was an event that happened to one man ages ago having nothing to do with the way we live our lives today, and saying for the thousandth time that resurrection of the body is not about the immortality of the soul nor essentially about an afterlife. I don't deny the immortality of the soul for a number of reasons, and I certainly don't assume a know-it-all stance about an afterlife. Yet I do know that what both notions miss is the radical affirmation of the body--and specifically the body's mortality. Until we embrace the body and stop repressing its instinctual and sensual life, not only are we plagued by our own neuroses but we continue on personal, social, cultural, and global levels to surrender to the death instinct. When Brown was writing in mid-twentieth century, it was clear that civilization had finally evolved to the point that it was capable of incinerating itself through unleashing hydrogen bombs. Now it is clear that the death instinct, masquerading in the garb of dominating "nature," has humans raping the ecosystem on a scale that is hurtling towards the brink of annihilation of ours and other species.

What to do? In a word, the only way out of the dilemma is to reconcile both the death and life impulses in the body. Because as long as we act as if we can deny death through "security," "power," accumulation, domination, fame or whatever, we will never get around to the one and only thing that can save us: profligate love, Eros rooted in the body, not confined to the sex organs but energizing the entire human organism, spilling over into erotic embrace of the entire universe.

So many voices are saying similar things today that finally it seems possible that Brown's vision might finally be realized: the hope that ultimately Eros would find itself prized and practiced by a humanity reveling in bodily life. This is not a matter of being "religious" or "secular." Nor does it mean abrogating morality, though it certainly moves the needle of the latter away from a prurient fixation with sexual manners and modalities.

Edward Knippers, Second Coming 
All those voices are echoes of what mystics of many traditions have been telling us for ages. Brown suggests that the principle gift of psychoanalysis is offering an objective critique of the inner life much as the natural sciences attempt to offer an objective account of the external world. Whether or not that can be done is a debatable question. But one thing is certain. The human mind's own debate about whether to follow its death instinct or its life impulse will never be settled through rationality, which is one form of sublimation and thus of repression. Poets, artists, shamans, musicians, and others who engage the imagination can lead us in embracing the world of paradox in all its dialectical complexity. And the way we'll discover it is through the very mortal bodies that hold our memories, our dreams, our desires, and the exhilarating power of pleasure.

That, I think, is the life of resurrection. And it's closer to us than the air we breathe.

© Frank Gasque Dunn, 2019



[1] Norman O. Brown, Life Against Death: The Psychoanalytical Meaning of History (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1959).

No comments: